Best Peyton Manning Jerseys, Merchandise, Autographs You Can Buy Today

Photo: Tony Medina/Icon Sportswire
Updated September 5, 2021

Peyton Manning is an absolute legend. But finding his jerseys, shirts, collectibles and other popular merchandise is not easy. 

The good news? Our NFL experts have scoured the Web looking for the best of the best. 

If you’re a Manning fan scroll down and find your favorite item. Our team makes sure every product is in stock and ready to buy. 

PEYTON MANNING JERSEYS

Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning Jersey - Mitchell & Ness Replica

Let’s start with our top pick. This Peyton Manning authentic jersey is from the Indianapolis Colts is an all-time NFL classic. 

Although it’s a replica, it has all the details of his real Colts jersey. It’s great for anyone that was a fan of his entire career and especially loved his legendary years in Indy. 

You can choose this blue Manning home jersey or a white away jersey by clicking the red PRICE button. 

Colts Manning Jersey - Mitchell & Ness White

If you're like me and you love a white NFL jersey we have the perfect item. 

The white Manning Colts jersey is harder to find than the blue edition. Click the PRICE button above and you'll soon be putting on this beautiful jersey on game day. 

Youth Denver Broncos Peyton Manning Nike Orange Team Color Game Jersey

This Peyton Manning Bronco jersey will only appear in stock a few times a year. So if you see your size buy it right away. You'll wear it forever. 

His years with Denver provided an incredible end to his long NFL career and included some of the most memorable Peyton Manning highlights

If you click the red PRICE button you'll see the full selection of sizes and editions for sale.  

PEYTON MANNING SHIRTS

Colts Peyton Manning Shirt - Mitchell & Ness Royal Retired Player Name & Number Mesh

We love the mesh name and number shirts from Mitchell & Ness, they are higher quality than most Peyton Manning shirts on the market. This is a high quality item and a must-have for every Manning fan. You get the same look and feel of a jersey at a much lower price point. 

Colts Manning Shirt - Fanatics Branded NFL Hall of Fame Class of 2021

If you're looking for Peyton Manning apparel at a lower price point than Mitchell & Ness, we have the perfect shirt. Sold for less $35 we can see why this shirt is the top selling Manning item at the NFL Store. An awesome shirt for Peyton's biggest fans. 

Broncos Peyton Manning Shirt - Fanatics Navy NFL Hall of Fame Class of 2021

Last but not least we have the classic Peyton Manning Broncos shirt. Includes his name and number and NFL Hall of Game logo. This shirt is rarely in stock, if you've been waiting for it go buy one now. During almost the entire 2020 season you couldn't find this shirt anywhere. 

PEYTON MANNING HOODIE

Omaha! Manning Hoodie - Broncos

A Peyton Manning hoodie with his famous “Omaha!” audible is hard to resist. A very comfortable hoodie and available in multiple colors. There's a lot of Peyton merchandise available at Amazon that aims to be more unique and fun than his typical fan gear.

PEYTON MANNING COLLECTIBLES

Manning is a legend of the game so there are many books written about him. He had a huge impact on the game of football and inspired a generation to strive for greatness. Here are the most highly rated Peyton Manning collectibles on Amazon:

The Mannings: The Fall and Rise of a Football Family

This book is a New York Times Bestseller and will take you through the rich history of the most well-known football family. If you’re a fan of Manning, this is a must read. This book not only covers Peyton but the other members of his family as well. There's a lot more to Peyton's story and this book does a great job of digging deep into this life and family. 

Peyton Manning Book: The Football Legend. The Incredible True Story of One of Football’s Greatest Players

This book is great if you love stats and specific games. It contains stats from each season as well as stats from pivotal games in Manning’s career with the Colts and the Broncos. For diehard fans this book provides a fascinating glimpse into some of his most famous moments on the field. 

Peyton Manning Book: The Last Rodeo

This book focused on Manning’s career with the Broncos. It tells the incredible story of his magical comeback season and contains many details the public has not heard before. If you want to learn more about his seasons in Denver this is the book to get. 

PEYTON MANNING POSTERS and COLLAGES

Indianapolis Colts Manning Plaque Fanatics Authentic 12" x 15" Super Bowl XLI Sublimated with Replica Ticket

A beautiful plaque celebrating the Colts Super Bowl XLI win in 2007. We love the replica game ticket and the photo of Peyton. This is an officially licensed NFL product from Fanatics Authentic. Arrives framed and ready to hang on any wall. 

Broncos Peyton Manning Memorabilia - Fanatics Authentic 10.5'' x 13'' Sublimated Player Plaque

If you're looking for an affordable Manning collectible this Denver Broncos wall plaque should be at the top of your list. A high quality officially licensed product at the NFL Shop, it arrives ready to hang in your home or office. 

Denver Broncos Manning Fanatics Authentic Framed 10" x 18" Panoramic with Piece of Game-Used Football - Limited Edition of 250

This is our top pick for a framed Peyton Manning photo from his seasons in Denver. It includes a piece of a game used football from a Broncos game. Only 250 of these were made so it's a valuable collectible that not many people will own. Authenticated by Fanatics and includes a statement of authenticity with purchase. 

PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARDS

Peyton Manning Rookie Cards - All Editions Graded and Verified

Peyton Manning rookie cards are very popular with collectors and hard to find. The inventory of cards available changes frequently so we recommend checking back here often. You can follow our live link to his rookie card listings at SportsMemorabilia.com.  They offer a lifetime authenticity guarantee, high quality graded cards, and lowest price guarantee. Click the red PRICE button takes you directly to the best Manning rookie card inventory. 

Peyton Manning Assorted Football Cards - Colts and Broncos

There are some awesome Manning football cards currently for sale if you're willing to look beyond rookie cards. You'll find a wide variety of price points and grading quality. Click the red PRICE button to see the complete inventory at guaranteed lowest prices. 

>>> We recommend checking out the full list of Manning cards available at SportsMemorabilia.com. There's currently a very good selection for sale. 

SIGNED PEYTON MANNING MEMORABILIA

Autographed Peyton Manning memorabilia are a different category of collectible and typically more expensive. The higher price is due to the limited quantities of signed items and the likelihood they will significantly increase in value. It’s important when looking at autographed products that you check the seller for authenticity. We only list items here from reliable and trustworthy retailers and individual sellers.  

>>> See out live link to the complete inventory of autographed Manning memorabilia at SportsMemorabilia.com. <<<

Peyton Manning Signed Helmet - Denver Broncos Riddell Mini Helmet with Deluxe Mini Helmet Case

The first autographed product is a Denver Broncos signed mini helmet. This is a dream item for every Manning fan and since it's a mini helmet it won't break the bank. If you can afford it this is one of the best Manning items you can buy and a hot selling collectible. 

Peyton Manning Signed Jerseys - Indianapolis Colts and Denver Broncos

When a batch of signed Peyton Manning jerseys hit the market they sell out very fast. Clicking the red PRICE button will take your directly to the latest inventory. You'll find Manning autographed jerseys from both the Broncos and Colts. All items personally hand signed by Manning and include an authenticity and low price guarantee. 

Manning Signed Photo - Indianapolis Colts Autographed 11" x 14" Blue Dropback Spotlight Photograph

Our top pick for Manning signed photos. This is a great image of Peyton getting ready to throw while playing for the Colts. Personally hand signed by Manning and includes a authenticity and low price guarantee. 

Peyton Manning Signed Football - Denver Broncos White Panel Football with "HOF 21" Inscription

This hand signed Manning football has been selling quickly over the past few months. It includes "HOF 21" honoring Peyton's induction into the NFL Hall of Fame. If you have the budget we highly recommend this item. 

>>> Looking for Manning signed football? Check out our full list of the best Peyton Manning signed footballs currently for sale. >>>

This is the end for our Ultimate Peyton Manning Guide. We hope you enjoyed reading it!

If you have any feedback get in touch with us at [email protected]

Thanks,

The Buy Side Sports Team