Buyer’s Guide – The Best Peyton Manning Signed Footballs For Sale

Peyton Manning football

Peyton Manning is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time. He was one of the best each and every year, shattering passing records throughout his stellar career. He led his teams to two Super Bowls. Manning also won multiple regular season MVPs along with being named in the First Team All-Pro numerous times. Since retiring the market for his collectibles has grown in value, and one of the hottest items is a Peyton Manning signed football. Below you’ll find a guide to the best and most valuable signed footballs available today.

Buying from a reputable seller like is the best way to safely buy autographed products. They provide an authenticity guarantee for all purchases. You can also browse the signed products for Peyton Manning on just ensure you look at the seller’s history to make sure the product has been authenticated.

Peyton Manning Denver Broncos Autographed 2016 White Panel Football

This list starts with a bang! A signed Super Bowl 50 white football from the Broncos. It’s an incredible piece of history to collect for both Manning and Broncos fans. It is signed by Manning contains all the Super Bowls won by the franchise. This ball was made right after the last Super Bowl win by Denver.

Why we love it:

  • Great piece of Broncos history

Peyton Manning Autographed Ball- Super Bowl 50 Curved Case Fanatics Hologram

The special feature about this signed football is the curved case hologram that’s included. It shows Manning after his Super Bowl win with the Broncos when they defeated the Carolina Panthers. The hologram makes this a unique collectible.

Why we love it:

  • The curved case hologram case

Peyton Manning Autographed Ball - Duke Fanatics

This signed football is from Manning’s first NFL team, the Indianapolis Colts. It’s a plain football with his signature on it. There are no extra logos or stamps on it so it’s a very clean, authentic signed item that showcases his signature.

Why we love it:

  • From his era with the Colts

Peyton Manning and Eli Manning Signed Official Wilson NFL Duke Football

Another great piece of NFL history, this signed football has the signature of both Peyton and Eli Manning. This product is authenticated and its value will only grow as both make the Hall of Fame. It’s very unique because it’s not every day that you get to buy a product signed by two brothers who won two Super Bowls each.

Why we love it:

  • Signed by Peyton and Eli Manning, brothers and NFL legends

Archie, Eli, and Peyton Manning Autographed Duke Pro Football

This one is a similar to the previously listed football, but another member of the legendary Manning family has added his signature. This person is none other than Archie Manning, the father of Peyton and Eli. It doesn’t get better than this in terms of value and football history. One of the most decorated families ever, the Mannings had a tremendous impact on the NFL.

Why we like it:

  • Signed by the three members of the legendary Manning family

1998 PRO BOWL Football Signed Peyton Manning Rookie And Terrell Davis

This is a must-have for every Broncos fan, it is autographed by Terrell Davis and Peyton Manning. It was signed way back at the 1998 Pro Bowl. Manning did not play because it was his rookie season, but Terrell Davis was one of the best running backs that season.

Why we like it:

  • Signed by two Hall of Famers

2004 Pro Bowl AFC Signed Football 56 Sigs! Peyton Manning, Ray Lewis and More

This signed football from the 2004 Pro Bowl features legends of the game and Hall of Famers. It contains 56 signatures, including NFL legends Peyton Manning and Ray Lewis. It also contains the 2004 Pro Bowl stamps on it. The football itself is an amazing gift or collector’s item. This one will not last long!

Why we like it:

  • 56 signatures of 2004 Pro Bowlers

Autographed Peyton Manning Ball

For our last Peyton Manning signed football we have a plain ball with his signature. It’s a classic NFL Football with no extra logos, stamps, or writing on it.

Why we like it:

  • Great gift for Manning fans

There are also some great display cases for autographed footballs. The cases help show off your signed ball and also protect it. You can check out some custom Peyton Manning football display cases here.

We hope you enjoyed our list of the best authentic Peyton Manning signed footballs. If you’d like to see a similar list for a different athlete, get in touch with us at [email protected].

BuySideSports is reader supported. When you click on product links we may earn a commission.

Player Product Guides