NFL Throwback Jerseys Buying Guide – Quarterback Edition

Joe Montana
Photo By: By Tony Bowler / Adobe
Updated July 22, 2021

It’s never the off-season when you’re looking for your all-time favorite NFL Throwback Jersey! Since quarterback is the most popular position we’ve come up with the best jerseys to help you make the right decision. Whether you want a favorite Packers jersey or you’re looking for the Joe ‘Cool’ 49ers jersey – we got you covered.

Best NFL Throwback Jerseys for Quarterbacks

1. John Elway Jersey – Denver Broncos NFL Throwback Jersey

A popular choice still today, have a look at Super Bowl XXXIII MVP John Elway’s number 7 orange NFL throwback jersey from Mitchell & Ness. Throughout his 16-year NFL career, Elway was known for his late game heroics in leading Denver to several last-minute comeback victories. Elway led the Broncos to consecutive Super Bowl appearances and won the 1987 NFL’s Most Valuable Player award. 

2. Peyton Manning Jersey – Indianapolis Colts Throwback Jersey

Mitchell & Ness offers a great looking replicate NFL throwback jersey for Peyton Manning. Manning has been touted as one of the most cerebral and physically talented quarterbacks to roam the NFL gridiron. After being named to the NFL’s All-Rookie team after the ’98 season, Peyton Manning went on to garnish the NFL Most Valuable Player award a record five times. 

>>> Check out our amazing guide for buying Peyton Manning Signed Footballs. <<<

3. Dan Marino Jersey – Miami Dolphins Throwback Jersey

There is no better way to celebrate the success of Dan Marino’s amazing career than this NFL retro jersey from Mitchell & Ness.  This official jersey features sewn-on numbers and nameplate and sizing is true-to-fit. You’ll represent your fan appreciation for the Miami Dolphins when you wear this fantastic find.

4. Troy Aikman Jersey – Dallas Cowboys NFL Throwback Jersey

If you're a Dallas Cowboys fan this throwback Aikman jersey equals a ‘must buy.’ The limited-edition jersey features a contoured and modern fit with flexible twill numbers and name. This NFL throwback jersey of the three-time Super Bowl champion is great to wear to a game or a sports bar. 

5. Joe Montana Jersey – San Francisco 49ers Throwback Jersey

When you’re looking for a topnotch 49ers retro NFL jersey, there’s no better choice than ‘Joe Cool,’ aka Joe Montana. Drafted out of Notre Dame he was the first NFL player to win three Super Bowl Most Valuable Player awards. His performances during the four title game wins resulted in his Super Bowl record for passer rating (127.8). 

6. Brett Favre Jersey – Green Bay Packers Throwback Jersey

You could say getting a Brett Favre Packers throwback jersey is really getting a "throwback of a throwback." Favre’s rough-and-tumble playing style brought up a lot of comparisons to the tough-as-nails quarterbacks roaming the football fields of the NFL in the era of the 1950s and 1960s.  Be a part of the ‘Lambeau Leap’ fan mentality while recognizing Favre’s terrific three-year consecutive run as NFL MVP. His performance during the 1996 Super Bowl season led the Packers to the team’s best performance in 30 years. A Favre NFL throwback jersey is a "can’t miss".

7. Terry Bradshaw Jersey – Pittsburgh Steelers NFL Throwback Jersey

A lot of quarterbacks have worn the number 12 but for the fans of Steelers Nation there will always be only one #12! Bradshaw and the Steelers would win a total of four NFL championships during a six-year period. He did while earning back-to-back Most Valuable Player awards in Super Bowls XIII and XIV. The feel of the tackle twill numbering is one of many advantages of this 100% polyester NFL retro jersey.

8. Bart Starr Jersey – Green Bay Packers NFL Throwback Jersey

The #15 is a prestigious reminder among Packers fans of all that was great about the dynasty of the 1960s. Starr is the only NFL quarterback to ever lead a team to three consecutive league championships. Named the Most Valuable Player in both Super Bowl I and Super Bowl II. The Bart Starr NFL throwback jersey is made of 100% polyester and is true-to-size fit.

9. Joe Namath Jersey – New York Jets Throwback Jersey

How popular is a Joe Namath NFL Throwback Jersey? Well, to paraphrase Broadway Joe himself, it’s a ‘guaranteed’ win. Namath, the first quarterback in the NFL ever to surpass 4,000-yards in passing, confidently predicted his New York Jets would win Super Bowl III. His MVP performance in the championship game cemented his name in NFL history. The true-to-size jersey allows for a snug fit and its 100% polyester fabric enhances the overall comfort.

10. Philadelphia Eagles Randall Cunningham Jersey - Mitchell & Ness Legacy Replica Jersey

Randall Cunningham had an incredible career spanning 16 years in the NFL. He spent the majority of his highlight reel years with the Philadelphia Eagles.  Forever remembered as one of the first quarterbacks to use speed and athleticism as a primary offensive weapon. He set numerous records with the Eagles and finished his career with stints in Minnesota and Dallas. This is a classic NFL throwback jersey for any fans of 1990s NFL Football.

We hope you enjoyed our list of the best NFL throwback jerseys for quarterbacks! Let us know if there are any former quarterbacks that you think we should have included. You can send recommendations to [email protected]