Buying Guide for Patrick Mahomes Rookie Sports Cards

Patrick Mahomes

The market for Patrick Mahomes rookie cards became red hot after he won the 2019 NFL MVP award. Below we’ve reviewed the best rookie cards available for sale that you can buy today. Mahomes has a long career ahead of him so there’s lots of potential for his rookie cards to increase in value.

We only review cards that are available to buy from reputable sellers such as If the seller is on Amazon, we make sure it’s a legit seller with high positive ratings. We also focus on retailers that provide a lifetime authenticity guarantee.

Patrick Mahomes II 2017 Leaf Draft #56 Rookie Card PGI 10 Pat

The first card on our list is a 2017 Leaf Draft rookie card. This card is notable because it’s likely the first sports card ever made for Mahomes. It’s rated a 10 (gem mint) and is considered rare and valuable. Not many Mahomes cards show him playing for Texas Tech.

You can also buy this card directly from Leaf Draft at a variety of price points and grading. Click here to see another excellent top rated edition of this Mahomes rookie card.

2017 Donruss Elite Draft Picks Patrick Mahomes Ii Rc Football Card Psa 9 Mint

This is another card showing Mahomes playing for Texas Tech. It’s been graded a 9 so it’s condition is high quality. There are not many of these cards available for sale so it’s a great find. Some collector’s prefer to purchase rookie cards with a photo from the player’s college career.

2017 Donruss Rated Rookie Patrick Mahomes Ii Rc Football Card #327 Psa 9 Mint

This 2017 Donruss card is part of a Rated Rookie set. It features Mahomes in his Kansas City Chiefs jersey. This is a popular card for collector’s with a strong re-sell market.

2017 Panini Rookies & Stars Purple #201 Pat Patrick Mahomes Chiefs Rookie Card

This is another Panini Mahomes rookie card. It shows him about to throw a pass for the Chiefs. It’s from the “Rookies & Stars” collection in 2017. There’s an active market for this card and the value keeps rising.

Patrick Mahomes 2017 Panini Donruss Elite Rookies #7 Rookie Football Card Psa 10

This Panini Donruss is from the 2017 Elite Rookies collection. It’s one of the best designed Mahomes rookie cards you’ll find. The pricing is competitive and you’ll have the safety of a lifetime authenticity guarantee.

Patrick Mahomes 2017 Panini Flawless RC Rookie Patch Silver PSA 6 AUTO 8 1/1 MVP - Football Slabbed Autographed Rookie Cards

Finally, if you want to know what it’s like shopping for an ultra premium sports card, click the link above. This is an incredible Patrick Mahomes rookie card. It’s one of the most sought after rookie cards from 2017. It’s literally a flawless one of kind collectors item.

We will keep watching the Patrick Mahomes rookie card market and make updates to this buying guide. If you want to get an idea of the complete selection of Mahomes rookie cards available check out the full list here. Just make sure you look for graded cards and reputable sellers. Often you’ll find the card manufacturers selling direct.

You dan also go direct to Sports Memorabilia and see their current selection of Mahomes cards.

If you see any Mahomes rookie cards you think we should include here, contact us at [email protected].


The BuySideSports Team

BuySideSports is reader supported. When you click on product links we may earn a commission.

Player Product Guides